Dare we go with classroom flow?

This week I participated in #edchatDe, a german twitterchat for educators.

One of the questions was :

Q2: What rules and rituals have you introduced to create a positive atmosphere? #EdchatDE

— EdchatDE (@EdchatDE) 19. november 2013

And my answer was:

@Lektoren I practise that sometimes. But – surprises and “adventurous lessons” own values as well, especially for younger students #edchatde

— snufkin (@frandevol) 19. november 2013

@frandevol’s answer gave me food for thought.

This week one of my lessons surprised me. I was introducing terms to poetry analysis; metaphors and so forth.

The lesson’s homework was a particular poem, and I had a scheduled plan, with an outline of the lesson’s conclusions ready in the back of my head, when I went into class.

Classroom parachuting?
CC-license, http://www.flickr.com/photos/usairforce/

Then one of the students talked passionately about another poem, and I decided to with her passion. She googled it and copied it into a shared Google Doc.

Bum. New agenda. Gamechanger.  New roles.

I wasn’t mr. know-it-all anymore. The student was ahead of me as she had worked with the poem before.

I had to start analyzing from scratch with the students. I didn’t have a suggested interpretation of the text beforehand. And it was fun!

‘Motivation’ is a current topic in Denmark’s educational debate. Some say that students are demotivated by not having influence on the agenda/curriculum. School is like a predictable film rolling before their eyes.

How hard do you stick to your lesson plans and how do you leave room for spontaneity in your planning?